Image: Bend Studio / PlayStationOfficial screenshot from Bend Studio / PlayStation.
Sarah's Gift is a Remastered trophy for finding a lost item that matters to Deacon. It comes from Horde Assault progress rather than the main story.
Play Horde Assault until you unlock the item.
The item is the custom fuel tank Sarah gave Deacon for his old bike. It unlocks as a Horde Assault reward and can then be fitted to the bike in every mode.
Image: Bend Studio / PlayStationFreakshow
Last 15 minutes in Horde Assault.
Image: Bend Studio / PlayStationI'm On Top of the World
Beat the target score on every level of Horde Assault.
Image: Bend Studio / PlayStationMore Freakers, More Problems
Beat a larger than normal Horde in Horde Assault mode.
Image: Bend Studio / PlayStationSurvivor
Reach the top level in Horde Assault.